[comdpa]

Nevermind, this should answer your question more clearly...

In the Preface of the 7th Edition:

"The "Uncompensated Stroke" is recommended simply because - for instance per 7-13 - if you cannot take the Shoulder down the Clubshaft Plane you must take it along some other path and add compensations - now, instead of one motion to remember, you wind up with at least two."

What did Mr. Kelly have to say about compensations?

Per 6-F-2 " Compensations are like temporary taxes - seldom eliminated and soon forgotten."

thanks compda

I might try a pm to Yoda for the other questions. I never seem to get anywhere on this topic

If you ever see an image showing the rear shoulder, forearm and clubshaft all on the same plane, during a normal golf shot and without a straight rear arm, please let me know . Push Elbow doesn't count