[neil]

Neil,

Just curious as to what you were looking at as I've never heard a definitive to look at a picture and tell if the player is swinging or hitting.

I've been told it's really what the player feels they are doing. For the right handed player do they feel like they're pushing with the right side or pulling with the left???

Also I believe a player can have the amount of hip rotation that Hogan does in the pictures and still hit (push).

However, with any player as long as the alignments (flying wedges intact) are solid and repeatable they will be succesful!!!

Sorting Through the Circuit Player's Handbook.

B-Ray

Agreed B Ray;
I just believe that Hogan was a swinger who pushed with his right arm-or thought he did.Maybe he did ,maybe it was his version of extensor action.
But I am certain he was a swinger -and therefore pulled.He may have pushed also-but he pulled.